Copycat Levain Bakery Dark Chocolate & PB Chip Cookies

A couple weekends ago, some of my bestest and oldest friends from home met in the big apple to visit my friend Casey who lives there. You may remember Casey from the Kitchen Bitchin’ archives a while back. Well – pssssh – that was soooooo last year. She has majorly upgraded and has a sweet bachelorette pad with closets (YES PLURAL) a stove AND a freezer. Baller status.

Copycat Levain Bakery Dark Chocolate & PB Chip Cookies

Central Park Selfie – Samsung totes wants it

One thing I love the most about these gals is our shared love of eating. We ate our way right through NYC (don’t worry we did other stuff – like drink some beer and sangria and sing karaoke). But we hit up some of the best spots in the city and in just about 24 hours I think we may have collectively consumed enough calories to feed an army (for like a week). Sunday morning, we rolled out of brunch, waddling through central park, thinking we couldn’t stomach one more morsel. Until Casey said “So, there’s this place that has really good cookies”. And suddenly, my stomach started to rumble.

Copycat Levain Bakery Dark Chocolate & PB Chip Cookies

We arrived at Levain Bakery and instantly I said “Ohhh this is the place that was on the Throwdown with Bobby Flay”. Thank god, because I think if I said “Ohhh that’s that place where this happened in Sex and the City” one more time, the gals were gonna send me on a slow boat across the Hudson. It’s a teeny, tiny, hole in the wall. With cookies. MASSIVE cookies. So natch, I got two: the chocolate chip w/ walnuts and the dark chocolate with PB chips. And while I’m usually a sucker for a chocolate chip (especially if it’s the size of my palm) I gotta tell you, this dark chocolate cookie with pb chips was devine. So devine that I came home, researched, went to the store TWICE to get the ingredients, and even made two separate recipes to try to recreate the magic that was.  And I gotta say, these.are. AWESOME!

They’re huge (1 batch only makes about 10 cookies). They use bread flour and all purpose flour, which helps hold their shape. The first batch I tried wasn’t quite chocolatey enough. So I tried again, adding more chocolate and switching a few steps up. And hello nail. Here’s the hammer, hitting you on the head (get it? I hit the nail on the….ah, nevermind….)

Copycat Levain Bakery Dark Chocolate & PB Chip Cookies

Copycat Levain Bakery Dark Chocolate & PB Chip Cookies
A copycat recipe for Levain Bakery's thick, chewy, dense Dark Chocolate cookies with Peanut Butter Chips
Write a review
  1. 1 & 1/4 cups all-purpose flour*
  2. 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons bread flour*
  3. 1/2 cup good quality cocoa powder*
  4. 1 teaspoon baking powder
  5. 1/4 teaspoon salt
  6. 8 oz semi-sweet chocolate bars, roughly chopped (I used TJ's dark chocolate 1lb bar)
  7. 1 cup (2 sticks) unsalted butter, cold and cubed
  8. 1 & 1/4 cups sugar
  9. 2 eggs, cold
  10. 2 cups peanut butter chocolate chips
  1. In a medium bowl, sift flours, cocoa powder, baking powder, and salt together; set aside.
  2. In a medium saucepan, melt your dark chocolate over a very low flame, stirring frequently until all pieces are melted. Set chocolate aside and let cool, but not so much that it starts to harden (about 5 minutes).
  3. In a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, cream together cold butter and sugar on medium speed. Add cold eggs, mix on medium speed. With the mixer still running, slowly pour your melted chocolate into the butter/sugar/egg mixture until all are fully incorporated.
  4. Slowly add the flour/cocoa mixture in small batches, continuing to mix on low speed until fully combined. Turn mixer off and gently fold in your peanut butter chips.
  5. Take about 1/2 cup of the dough (it will be very sticky), roughly roll between your palms and place on a lightly greased baking sheet. You should get just about 10 balls of dough. Freeze the balls of dough for 1 hour.
  6. Preheat your oven to 350 degrees F.
  7. On a parchment lined baking sheet, place 6-8 of the dough balls (they don't spread much so don't worry about them running into each other during baking). Bake cookies in preheated oven for 18-24 minutes. If you like a gooey center, 18-20 minutes; if you like more of a cooked center 22-24. Let them cool on the baking sheet for 5 minutes, and then transfer them to a wire rack to cool completely. Serve right away or store in an air tight container for 4-5 days.
  1. The proper way to measure flour entails gently whisking it in the canister or bag and then spooning it into your measuring cup, then leveling the excess off with a knife. If you just dunk the measuring cup into the bag or canister of flour, you could end up using twice as much flour as necessary, which will totally throw off your recipe.
  2. I used just regular cocoa powder for these cookies. But you could also use Dark cocoa powder to make them that much more dark chocolatey.
Adapted from Recipe Carr
Adapted from Recipe Carr
And They Cooked Happily Ever After


Paella Mixta (Paella with Seafood, Spanish Chorizo & Chicken)

March 26, 2014
Paella Mixta (Paella with Seafood, Spanish Chorizo and Chicken)

I spent a semester abroad in Spain in college and there was this funny named dish with rice and a bunch of other stuff I didn’t really like and was kind of hard to say (but not really).  So I may have had it like once while I was there. BOY am I kicking myself […]

Read the full article →

Cadbury Egg (BOTH KINDS) Skillet Brownies

March 21, 2014
Cadbury Egg Skillet Brownies

Guys. I haven’t been posting much lately. So when I do, I make sure it’s GOOOOOOD. Life has been cray cray biz, mostly with work. Just like that it’s Spring! And it just so happens that today is my (blank blank) birthday! You can insert any number you wish in there (ok….it’s thirty…..t….t…t…w….o)…phew. Lucky for […]

Read the full article →

Pat’s Stacked Enchiladas

February 28, 2014

Dave plays adult league men’s hockey.  Anyone who knows someone who plays in these leagues knows that these games occur at the most ungodly hours of the evening when most normal people would be getting into bed.  Normally, a wife would get aggravated when she’s awoken in the early hours of the morning by her […]

Read the full article →

Easy Chicken Pot Pie for Two

February 19, 2014
Easy Chicken Pot Pie for Two

What is it about Chicken Pot Pie that makes people (or just me) weak in the knees? Like literally – jello knees – or now  I will call them Pot Pie knees.  Maybe cuz’ I’ve been eating it since I was a young tike. Or because it involves buttery pie crust and gravy. I’ll say […]

Read the full article →

Rich Chocolate Caramel Cake

February 14, 2014
Chocolate Caramel Cake

The only time I’ll pass on dessert is if it doesn’t involve chocolate. I like chocolate – and I like cake – and I like them together.  A lot. I first saw this gem on Yums and Loves. I’ve been following Alex for a while and she has the cutest little nugget of a daughter […]

Read the full article →

9 Killer Superbowl Party Recipes

January 30, 2014
Superbowl Recipes

Superbowl Sunday is in FOUR days! (Yet I’ve already watched the Budweiser Superbowl commercial with the puppy in it enough times to mimick everything that happens in it).   It may just be one if the best days of the year, even if your team (AHEM) isn’t on the field – there’s something for everyone: […]

Read the full article →

Grammy Murphy’s Whoopie Pies

January 27, 2014
Grammy Murphy's Whoopie Pies

They say you can’t pick the family you’re born into. You never know when you take your first breaths out of mom’s belly who you’re relatives will be. They could be Mimes. Circus people. Car thiefs. The possibilities are endless.  I myself was born into a family of bakers. For as long as I can […]

Read the full article →

One-Pot Chicken Broccoli Ziti

January 24, 2014
One-Pot Chicken Broccoli Ziti

Life is hectic.  Eating Dinner is mandatory. That is why one-pot dishes exist. Ever since making this, I’ve been trying to find the best one-pot dishes around. But I never expected to find an entire SECTION in an old America’s Test Kitchen cookbook that my mom got me for Christmas ages ago.  That’s where I […]

Read the full article →

Oreo Pretzel Toffee Brittle

January 15, 2014
Oreo Pretzel Toffee Brittle

I’m not even gonna start out with a “OMGGG it’s been so long since I last wrote a Blog post”.  That my friends, is pretty obvious. The Holidays were the usual nuttiness and having Thanksgiving so late really threw off my mojo (How many times did you hear that this year?) I told myself in […]

Read the full article →